Cryptocurrencies have become a crucial part of the global financial system in recent years. However, despite the growth in value and adoption, the legal status of crypto assets remains ambiguous as most countries still need to establish comprehensive laws to govern them. In the United States, cryptocurrency control has become a focal point for politicians and financial regulators. This article explores the reasons behind tightening cryptocurrency regulations in the U.S. and draws parallels with the situation in South and Southeast Asian countries.
In the world of cryptocurrency investors and traders, it’s often said: ‘Regulations kill innovation.’ But is this the case? In the USA, the crackdown on cryptocurrencies is already gaining momentum, raising serious questions about the future of this industry. Meanwhile, South and Southeast Asian countries also witness increased cryptocurrency regulation, making for interesting comparisons.
Key reasons for tightening regulation
Consumer protection and fraud prevention
Cryptocurrency transactions are often anonymous, making them attractive to fraudsters. Recent cases of large-scale cryptocurrency fraud have prompted regulators to tighten controls to protect consumers.
Anti-money laundering (AML) efforts
Cryptocurrencies are frequently used for money laundering and terrorist financing. The U.S., like many other countries, aims to prevent such activities through stricter regulation.
Financial stability
The volatility of cryptocurrencies has the potential to impact financial systems negatively. U.S. authorities fear that the widespread use of cryptocurrencies could destabilise the economy; hence, they seek to limit their use.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) play critical roles in cryptocurrency regulation. The SEC considers many cryptocurrencies securities and requires their registration, which has sparked considerable debate among market participants.
In the U.S., several specific laws and legislative efforts have significantly impacted the cryptocurrency landscape. The ‘Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act,’ signed into law in 2021, included regulations requiring cryptocurrency exchanges and brokers to report transactions to the IRS, thereby increasing transparency and reducing tax evasion. Additionally, the ‘Digital Asset Market Structure and Investor Protection Act,’ proposed in 2022, aims to establish a comprehensive regulatory framework for digital assets, including clear definitions and roles for regulatory bodies like the SEC and CFTC. In 2024, new legislation is being developed to tighten these regulations further, focusing on stricter KYC (Know Your Customer) requirements, enhancing anti-money laundering protocols, and increasing oversight of decentralised finance (DeFi) platforms. These efforts reflect a growing recognition of the need to balance innovation with robust regulatory oversight to protect consumers and maintain financial stability.
The tightening of regulations in the U.S. significantly impacts the global cryptocurrency market. As one of the largest markets, any changes in regulatory policy here create ripples across all cryptocurrency markets. Stricter regulation might reduce the attractiveness of cryptocurrencies for investors but could also increase their security and stability.
Cryptocurrency regulation also affects local markets in South and Southeast Asia. Bans and restrictions can slow the development of the cryptocurrency sector but also help protect consumers and reduce risks associated with fraud and illegal activities.
India
India’s regulatory environment for cryptocurrencies has been tumultuous. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) imposed a banking ban on crypto businesses in 2018, which the Supreme Court overturned in 2020. However, the government continues to explore stringent regulations, including a potential ban on private cryptocurrencies and the development of a central bank digital currency (CBDC).
Malaysia
Malaysia’s approach to cryptocurrency regulation is progressive yet cautious. The Securities Commission Malaysia (S.C.) regulates initial coin offerings (ICOs) and cryptocurrency exchanges under the Capital Markets and Services (Prescription of Securities) (Digital Currency and Digital Token) Order 2019. This regulation ensures that digital asset activities meet investor protection and market integrity standards.
Singapore
Singapore has established itself as a crypto-friendly jurisdiction with clear regulatory guidelines. The Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) regulates cryptocurrencies under the Payment Services Act (PSA), ensuring compliance with AML and counter-terrorism financing (CTF) laws. This act requires cryptocurrency service providers to be licensed and adhere to strict operational standards.
By addressing these diverse regulatory approaches, South and Southeast Asian countries strive to balance innovation in the cryptocurrency sector with financial stability and consumer protection.
Regulation can legitimise the cryptocurrency industry, attract institutional investors, and foster mainstream adoption. Establishing clear rules and regulations helps enhance consumer protection, reduce fraud, and prevent money laundering. Regulatory frameworks can promote market stability and protect the financial system from the volatility associated with cryptocurrencies,’ said Kar Yong Ang, a financial market analyst for Octa broker.
On the downside, excessive regulation might stifle innovation by imposing burdensome compliance costs on startups and smaller companies. It can also limit the privacy and anonymity that many cryptocurrency users value. Over-regulation could push businesses and investors to jurisdictions with more lenient policies, potentially losing competitive advantage for heavily regulated regions.
Potential future of cryptocurrencies after U.S. election
If Trump wins
If Donald Trump wins the 2024 presidential election, his administration will likely treat cryptocurrencies more favourably. Trump’s campaign has embraced a pro-crypto agenda. His platform includes defending the right to mine Bitcoin, ensuring Americans can self-custody their digital assets, and opposing the creation of a central bank digital currency (CBDC). Trump’s approach aims to foster innovation and reduce regulatory burdens on the cryptocurrency industry, which could lead to increased growth and investment in the sector.
If Kamala Harris wins
Conversely, if Kamala Harris wins the election, her administration might take a more cautious and regulatory approach to cryptocurrencies. Although Harris has not fully outlined her stance on crypto, the Democratic Party has generally favoured stricter regulations to protect consumers and ensure financial stability. This could include implementing more rigorous know-your-customer (KYC) and anti-money laundering (AML) standards and greater oversight of cryptocurrency exchanges and stablecoins. Harris’s administration might also explore the development of a CBDC to modernise the financial system, focusing on enhancing security and transparency while preventing the misuse of digital assets  .
The outcome of the 2024 U.S. presidential election will significantly shape the future regulatory landscape for cryptocurrencies, balancing innovation with consumer protection and financial stability.
The evolving regulatory frameworks in the U.S. and South and Southeast Asia will play a crucial role in cryptocurrencies’ global adoption and development. As these regions refine their approaches, the industry must navigate new rules and adapt to changing conditions. Ultimately, achieving a balance between innovation and regulation will be critical to the sustainable growth of the cryptocurrency market.
However, effective regulation of cryptocurrencies requires global coordination. ‘Cryptocurrencies operate on a global scale, and regulation in one region can only limit the industry’s growth locally without addressing broader issues,’ Kar Yong Ang remarked. ‘Since the U.S. has some of the most developed laws regarding financial markets and investor protection, it is a significant trendsetter in this area,’ he added. Coordinated international regulatory efforts are essential to ensuring that cryptocurrencies can develop in a way that protects consumers, maintains financial stability, and fosters innovation across the globe.
Boilerplate:
Octa is an international broker that has been providing online trading services worldwide since 2011. It offers commission-free access to financial markets and various services already utilised by clients from 180 countries with more than 42 million trading accounts. Free educational webinars, articles, and analytical tools they provide help clients reach their investment goals.
The company is involved in a comprehensive network of charitable and humanitarian initiatives, including the improvement of educational infrastructure and short-notice relief projects supporting local communities.
Octa has also won over 70 awards since its foundation, including the ‘Best Educational Broker 2023’ award from Global Forex Awards and the ‘Best Global Broker Asia 2022’ award from International Business Magazine.
